August 26. John Winthrop. Winthrop was elected governor of Massachusetts Bay Colony, which Winthrop called,“a city upon a hill, before the Puritans ever left England. The great hope was that the settlement would allow them to pursue their religious beliefs without persecution.
Punishment can correct the offender; mercy can restore him.
Winthrop watched the snow fall as another Massachusetts winter blasted Boston. It wasn’t his first winter, nor would it be his last, but every year it was the same. Freezing temperatures. Howling winds. Blizzards that dumped piles of snow and ice that disrupted the town.
Worst of all, these winters lasted much longer than the winters in England, and that meant suffering. Already he had seen hundreds of people die or flee the settlement because of lack of food and prevalence of disease. Surely this winter would bring about just as much hardship, … and he would have to lead them through it.
One of the settlers approached, and he seemed upset. And Governor Winthrop acknowledged the settler and asked him what was wrong.
The man quickly said he was happy Winthrop was alone. The man didn’t want to make a scene, but someone had been going onto his property and stealing wood from his woodpile.
Winthrop’s temper flared. Boston was supposed to be a holy and righteous city that followed God’s Word. Stealing was certainly not allowed! Didn’t the thief realize how cold it had been? Did he want the poor man to suffer from a lack of wood for the fire?
“I’ll take a course with him,” Winthrop said. And he was fuming. “Go, call that man to me; I’ll warrant you I’ll cure him of stealing.”
The settler gave a nod, hurried off to find the thief, and led him back to the governor for punishment.
But when Winthrop beheld the thief, seeing how poor and ragged he was, he suddenly realized he had been too quick to judge.
The thief explained why he had stolen the wood. He was freezing in the unending cold that had killed so many people when they had first arrived in Massachusetts. He didn’t want to steal the wood, but he felt as if he had no other choice. Boston had little wood to go around, since many of the trees had been felled to make homes and buildings. How else was he to stay warm?
The Governor thought of all the times he had witnessed poverty among other people. If ever there was a family who needed food or money, he had given it to them out of his own pocket and supply. They had never been tempted to steal because they had been provided for. Didn’t God command his people to take care of the poor and needy? How could he call himself a Christian, let alone the governor of Massachusetts, if he didn’t care for the least of his people? When he gave to the poor, he gave glory to God.
Stealing was wrong. Winthrop knew this, and there was plenty of punishment that could be done. But if he only punished the thief without curing the root of his stealing, how would he help the thief turn back to God and righteousness?
Winthrop knew what to do to cure the root of the problem, and he turned to the thief. “Friend,” he began, “it is a severe winter, and I doubt you are but meanly provided for wood; wherefore I would have you supply yourself at my wood pile till this cold season be over.”
The thief was shocked, thankful for the governor’s generosity. He would not have to steal any more wood that winter.
“Whoever is kind to the poor lends to the LORD, and He will reward them for what they have done” (Proverbs 19:17 NIV).
How might you be able to help the needy today? Punishment can correct the offender; mercy can restore him.
ushistory.org. “Massachusetts Bay—‘The City Upon a Hill.’” Accessed June 22, 2020. https://www.ushistory.org/us/3c.asp.
Bremer, Francis J. “John Winthrop.” Reviewed January 22, 2015. https: //www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199827251/obo-9780199827251–0028. xml.
Story read by: Blake Mattocks
Introduction read by: Daniel Carpenter
Audio production: Joel Carpenter
Editor: Teresa Crumpton, https://authorspark.org/
Project Manager: Blake Mattocks
Copyright 2020, 365 Christian Men, LLC. All rights reserved.